top of page

Online Ordering

You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.

Not Accepting Orders

Fish Market

If there is something that you want in particular , please don't hesitate to ask.

Fillets

Fillets

*Note that the price per pound is indicative. Every piece of seafood has to be weighed in order to have the actual price. Please place your order and, once we receive it, we will process it and we will call you with a final price.

Scottish Salmon

Scottish Salmon is a premium farmed Atlantic salmon that is sustainably raised off the coast of Scotland.

$20.99

Scottish Salmon

Flounder (fluke)

Local flounder. caught off Cape May NJ

$23.95

Flounder (fluke)

Monkfish

Local Monkfish caught off Cape May NJ

$11.95

Monkfish

Swordfish

Caught off North Carolina *Please specify how thick you would like it cut.

$19.95

Swordfish

Yellowfin Tuna

Product of USA Locally Caught

$21.95

Yellowfin Tuna

Branzino Fillet

Branzino, also known as European sea bass, is a popular and healthy seafood choice, particularly enjoyed in Italian and Mediterranean cuisines.

$21.95

Chilean Seabass

$0.00

Red Snapper Fillet

Product of USA Caught in Florida *Please specify if you would like skin on or skin off

$22.95 - Unavailable

Red Snapper Fillet

Halibut

Product of USA Caught off Maine

$28.95 - Unavailable

Halibut

Grouper

Product of USA. Caught in Florida

$25.95 - Unavailable

Grouper

Black Sea Bass

Product Of USA Caught in New Jersey

$28.95 - Unavailable

Black Sea Bass

Wild King Salmon

Wild Alaskan King Salmon is the largest and most rich flavored of all the species of wild salmon.

$28.95 - Unavailable

Wild King Salmon

Wild Coho Salmon

Caught in Alaska

$0.00 - Unavailable

Wild Coho Salmon

Golden Tilefish

Wild caught off of New Jersey

$21.00 - Unavailable

Golden Tilefish

Bluefish

Local bluefish fillet

$8.99 - Unavailable

Bluefish
Whole Fish

Whole Fish

*Please specify how you would like us to prepare the fish.*

Whole Black Seabass

Product of USA Caught in New Jersey

$9.95

 Whole Black Seabass

Whole Red Snapper

Caught in Florida.

$10.95

Whole Red Snapper

Whole Branzino

$10.95

Golden Tilefish

$0.00 - Unavailable

Golden Tilefish
Shellfish

Shellfish

Local

Scallops (10/20 count)

Local Sea Scallops from Cape May NJ.

$29.50

Scallops   (10/20 count)

Oysters

Ask what is available at the time of purchase

$20.75

Oysters

Clams

Local hard clams that have a distinct salty sweet flavor

$6.25

Clams

Fresh Crabmeat

Fresh Crabmeat

$36.00

Fresh Crabmeat

Pasteurized Crabmeat

$0.00

Pasteurized Crabmeat

Mussels

Prince Edward Island (PEI) Mussels Cleaned and debearded. *note . QTY # represents lbs.

$5.95

Mussels

Raw Large Wild Shrimp (16-20 count)

Please specify if you want them cleaned. Note: there is a peel & devein fee of $2 per lb

$18.99

Raw Large Wild Shrimp (16-20 count)

U-30 Crab Claws

U-30 Crab Claws *note the total claws in each can varies, 12oz per can. Approximately 20-28 pieces per can

$0.00

U-30 Crab Claws

Jumbo Softshell Crabs

Softshell crabs are an iconic, delicious and timeless summer treat.

$9.95

Jumbo Softshell Crabs

Frying oysters

Large Local Delaware Bay oysters. Freshly shucked and packed in 16oz container.

$25.00

Frying oysters

Live Lobsters

Maine Lobster all sizes special order only! Market Price

$0.00

(Whales) Softshell Crabs

Softshell crabs are an iconic, delicious and timeless summer treat.

$0.00 - Unavailable

(Whales) Softshell Crabs
Frozen Seafood

Frozen Seafood

Vacuum Sealed Seafood

We can portion and vacuum seal a wide variety of seafood for you to stock up your freezer and eat your seafood whenever you would like. * All orders for this service must be ordered at least 24 hours in advance.

$0.00

Lobster Tails

4oz, please specify which size 9oz, 10/12 oz

$34.95

Lobster Tails

Squid (Calamari)

Locally caught squid cut in Rings & Tentacles

$11.99

Produce

Fresh local produce with a growing organic selection

Salad Vegetables

Salad Vegetables

Family farm fresh greens that are harvested and packed daily.

Organic Spring mix

Spring Mix is made up of a variety fresh greens and lettuces of varying tastes and textures, including red romaine, baby spinach, green romaine, red oak leaf, red leaf, lollo rosso, arugula, red chard, and baby kale .

$3.75

Organic Spring mix

Organic Spinach

Baby Spinach is bright green with gently rounded leaves. The chewy texture of the young leaves is crisp yet succulent. Sweeter than mature spinach, Baby Spinach offers a delicate nuttiness with subtle flavor and tender, edible stems.

$3.75

Organic Spinach

Organic Baby Kale

Baby Kale is the Lacinato or “dinosaur” variety, also known as Cavolo Nero or Black Tuscan Kale. This is a famously rugged variety with a deep, earthy flavor and thick, crinkled leaves. This baby version is cut when still small and tender – perfect for the salad bowl or using as a garnish. You still get the forest flavor of the large leaves but in a more delicate, slightly peppery flavor, similar to arugula.

$3.75

Organic Baby Kale

Organic Wild Arugula

5oz Baby arugula is simply arugula harvested young for its more petit, delicate leaves and flavor. Although not as intense in flavor as its mature counterparts, it still retains that peppery essence and mustard quality that distinguishes arugula from other herbs and leafy greens.

$3.75

Organic Wild Arugula

Kale

Fresh Local wild kale

$2.99

Kale
Onions

Onions

A wide selection of onions. From roasting, to caramelizing, to dicing and creating your favorite dishes.

Shallots

Shallots are aromatic, spicy, sweet, and crisp when raw and when cooked, they develop a delicate, sweet, and savory flavor with notes of garlic.

$0.00

 Shallots

Spanish Onions

$0.00

Spanish Onions

Scallions

$0.00

Scallions

Red Onion

$0.00

Red Onion
Mushrooms

Mushrooms

No items to show yet

Check back soon for new items.

Fruit

Fruit

Lemons

$1.00

Lemons

Limes

$1.25

Limes

Jersey Tomatoes

$2.99

Jersey Tomatoes
Vegetables

Vegetables

Red Skin Potatoes

$0.00

Red Skin Potatoes

Idaho Baking Potato

$0.00

Idaho Baking Potato

Carrots

carrots 1lb bag

$0.00

Carrots

Broccoli

$0.00

Broccoli

Sweet Potatoes

Jumbo Sweet Potatoes

$0.00

Sweet Potatoes

Radish

$2.99

Radish

Celery

Medium Celery

$0.00

Celery

Fresh Garlic

sleeve

$0.00

Fresh Garlic

Local Corn on the cob

Fresh Local white corn.

$1.00

Local Corn on the cob

Green Cabbage

$0.00

Green Cabbage

Red Cabbage

$0.00

Red Cabbage

Beets

Fresh beets. Grown locally.

$0.00

Beets

Eggplant

locally grown eggplant

$0.00

Eggplant

Cucumber

$0.00

Cucumber

Ginger

Fresh ginger

$0.00

Ginger

Red bell peppers

$0.00

Red bell peppers

Asparagus

Jersey Asparagus

$4.99 - Unavailable

Asparagus
Herbs

Herbs

Cilantro

$2.99

Cilantro

Parsley

$1.99

 Parsley

Basil

$2.99

Basil

Thyme

$0.00

Dill

$2.99

Dill

Mint

$2.99

Mint

Prepared Foods

Small selection of healthy staples you can add to your meal to round it up and to make it more wholesome. We make everything from scratch, starting with just fresh vegetables.

Cold Salads

Cold Salads

Beet Salad

Fresh beets, red onion, extra virgin olive oil, red wine vinegar, cracked peppercorn and salt

$0.00

Beet Salad

French Potato Salad

Red Skinned Potatoes, Shallots, Red Wine Vinegar, Olive Oil, Dijon Mustard, Salt.

$0.00

French Potato Salad

Cole Slaw

Red Cabbage, Green Cabbage, Carrots, Homemade Dressing

$0.00

Cole Slaw

Fresh Tuna salad

House made from local yellowfin tuna, mayonnaise, celery, red onion, dijon mustard, salt and pepper

$0.00

Fresh Tuna salad

Cucumber Salad

cucumbers, dill, sour cream and salt

$0.00

Cucumber Salad

Shrimp Salad

Wild caught gulf shrimp with mayonnaise, celery, scallions, toasted almonds, tarragon, lemon juice and salt

$0.00

Shrimp Salad
Cook at home

Cook at home

Crabcake

$0.00

Stuffies

Cherrystone clam that is stuffed with chopped clam, red bell pepper, thyme, sage, rosemary, bread crumbs and parmesan cheese. Reheat 375 degrees 8-10 min

$0.00

Stuffies

Clam Casino

Topneck clam that has the whole clam, red bell pepper, bread crumb mix and a slice of bacon. Reheat 375 degrees 8-10min

$0.00

Clam Casino

Salmon Burgers

$0.00

Salmon Burgers

Dry Goods

Dry goods

Dry goods

Hanks Sauce

$0.00

Hanks Sauce

Sriracha

$0.00

Sriracha

Tabasco

$0.00

Tabasco

Tapatio

$0.00

Tapatio

Capers

$11.99 - Unavailable

Salmon Rub

$3.75 - Unavailable

Old Bay Blackened

$3.99 - Unavailable

Old Bay Blackened

Old Bay Regular 6oz

$6.99 - Unavailable

Old Bay Regular 2.62oz

$2.50 - Unavailable

Sauces

Condiments

Condiments

Cocktail Sauce

Our house recipe of cocktail sauce. Not too spicy.

$0.00

Cocktail Sauce

Tartar Sauce

Our French recipe of tartar sauce, with 0 sugar and all the tang.

$0.00

Tartar Sauce

Mango Salsa

Summer in a sauce. Fresh mango, red onion, red peppers.

$0.00

Mango Salsa

Sriracha Mayo

$0.00

Sriracha Mayo

Horseradish

$0.00

Horseradish

Imports

Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Extra Virgin Olive Oil

100% Arbequina olive Spanish oil. Full bodied. Use raw on salads or drizzle over grilled seafood and soups.

Extra Virgin Olive Oil

100% Arbequina olive Spanish oil. Full bodied. Use raw on salads or drizzle over grilled seafood and soups.

$0.00

Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Canned Seafood

Canned Seafood

Canned seafood is tradition in the Mediterranean countries where it is an essential part of Sunday appetizing. This canned seafood is from the Azores Island, off Portugal's coast. Every can is hand prepared and it is preserved in Extra Virgin Olive oil or brine, then sterilized without the use of unnatural preservatives. The result is a natural fish with a taste unlike anything you have had from a can. The tuna, sardines and squid are caught using the best fishing practices, the protection of dolphins, and sustainability of the sea. They are guaranteed by the "Friend of the Sea" certification.

Sardines (Extra Virgin Olive Oil)

Sardines canned in extra virgin olive oil. Delicious on toasted bread with a drizzle of hot sauce, if you like it.

$2.99

Sardines (Extra Virgin Olive Oil)

Sardines (Tomato Sauce)

Sardines canned in a very mildly spicy tomato sauce. Delicious on toasted bread with a drizzle of olive oil.

$2.99

Sardines (Tomato Sauce)

Solid Tuna in Olive Oil

Solid tuna canned in extra virgin olive oil. So good, you will eat it straight out of the can.

$4.99

Solid Tuna in Olive Oil

Sardines (Skinless and Boneless in olive oil)

These sardines are canned in extra virgin olive oil. No skin or bones.

$3.99

Sardines (Skinless and Boneless in olive oil)

Stuffed Squid

Stuffed squid in "sauce americaine", a French sauce made of onions, tomatoes, brandy and cayenne pepper.

$3.99

Stuffed Squid

Chopped Jumbo Squid in Garlic Sauce

$3.99

Cheese

Cheese

Manchego cheese are a wonderful Spanish cheese made with goat milk. Delicious, and lactose free.

No items to show yet

Check back soon for new items.

Party Trays

Party Trays

Party Trays

Wild Jumbo Shrimp

$49.00

Wild Jumbo Shrimp

Cold Salad Trays

Beet salad, Coleslaw, Potato salad and Cucumber salad

$25.00

Cold Salad Trays

Crudités

Serves 4-6

$25.00

Gift Certificates

Gift Certificates

Gift Certificates

Gift Certificate

$0.00

Gift Certificate

Desserts

Pies, cookies, biscotti

Homemade pies

Homemade pies

Key lime

$4.00

Key lime

Fruit crumb

$4.00

Fruit crumb

Biscotti

$0.00

Biscotti

Bread

Fresh Baked Bread

Bread

Bread

Ciabatta

$0.00

Ciabatta

Sourdough

$0.00

Sourdough

French Baguette

$0.00

206 West Mechanic Street

Cape May Court House NJ 08210

Fall Hours: 

Wednesday- Saturday 10-8

​Sundays- Closed

Matthews Gift Cards are here!

We have two designs to choose from. Ask at counter.

Photography by Dawn Dudley

 Web Design ©2018 by Yvonne Yuen

bottom of page