206 West Mechanic Street

Cape May Court House NJ 08210

Open- Wednesday-Saturday 10am-7pm

Closed- Sunday

Matthews Gift Cards are here!

We have two designs to choose from. Ask at counter.

Photography & Web Design ©2018 by Yvonne Yuen

Our Market

We specialize in fresh seafood and prepared foods that you can take home and broil, bake or simply throw on the grill for an easy weeknight or weekend dinner. From whole fish to roast or grill to other hard-to-find seafood, let us know what kind of fish you like and we will get it for you!

We are committed to fresh seafood so our selection is subject to seasonality. What you will find regularly stocked at Matthews includes: Cape May Sea Scallops, North Atlantic Cod, Swordfish, Monkfish, Local Flounder, Scottish Salmon, Wild Shrimp, and Cape May Salt Oysters. Pick a catch to cook at home; Tom and his team is always available with cooking tips for a perfect meal.

In our prepared foods section, you will find New England Clam Chowder, Maryland Crab Bisque, French Mussel Bisque, a variety of salads, plus crab cakes and salmon burgers, stuffies and casinos, ready to go. Everything is housemade, of course!